NOTE: When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission.
Learn more*
Best Match
Newest
Ending
Lowest Price
Highest Price
Best Match
Newest
Ending
Lowest Price
Highest Price
S
M
L
XL
Share
Share
Twitter
Facebook
Email
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$19.99
Antique Silverplate REED & BARTON Pictorial Dessert Forks Pilgrim Alden Lot of 2
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$27.09
Pilgrim Silver, Footed Hot Plate Trivet-Silverplate (8")
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$19.00
Hibbard Spencer Bartlett OVB PILGRIM Cold Meat Serving Fork 8-1/4" Silverplate
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$69.00
Lot of 11 Pilgrim Butter Spreader Knives OVB Our Very Best Silver Plate 1911
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$9.99
Antique Hibbard Spencer Bartlett OVB Pilgrim Butter Sugar Spoon Silverplate
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$11.99
Antique Silverplate REED & BARTON Pictorial Dessert Fork John Alden Pilgrim
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$6.50
Vintage OVB Hibbard Spencer Bartlett Sugar Spoon Silverplate - Pilgrim Pattern
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$22.00
International Silver Co. Large 14.5” Pilgrim Silver Plated Punch Ladle
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$19.50
PILGRIM 1911 Antique Silverplate Preserve or Jam Spoon No Monograms L
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$12.60
Vtg Our Very Best OVB Silver Plate Double Spout Gravy Sauce Ladle HTF 6.5-7 inch
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$12.00
Hibbard Spencer Bartlett OVB PILGRIM 3 Serving Spoons 8-1/8" Silverplate 1911
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$20.00
Vintage Pilgrim Silver Co Double Plate 6 Forks 6” ENGRAVED
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$60.00
6pc HIBBARD SPENCER BARTLETT O.V.B. PILGRIM PIE FORKS 7"
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$17.99
VINTAGE PILGRIM SILVER CO FORK SERVING DOUBLE PLATE
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$23.00
2 PC Set, Vintage Pilgrim Silver Co. Silver Plated Butter Knife’s Late 1940’s
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$11.00
Antique Pilgrim Silver Co. KA Butter Knife
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$30.00
Antique pilgrim spoon Holy Figure EPNS 1910 4.25”
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$24.50
PILGRIM 1911 Cold Meat Serving Fork Silverplate No Monogram G
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$6.99
Pilgrim Silver Co. Spoon Double Plate 6 Inch
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$25.00
Vintage Pilgrim Silver Co Double Plate 6 Forks 6”
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$49.99
Large 12.5” pilgrim Silver plate punch ladle P683
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$2.50
Pilgrim Silver Co. Spoon Double Plate 6 Inch
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$40.00
WMF Cromargan Sugar Shovel ~ Germany ~ Stainless Steel
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$9.99
Vtg Hibbard Spencer Bartlett OVB Pilgrim cold meat serving silverplate fork
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$42.00
Pilgrim Silver Company Double Plate lot of 6 Spoons
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$3.00
Hibbard Spencer Bartlett OVB PILGRIM 2 Serving Spoons 8-1/8" Silverplate 1911 A1
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$12.49
OVB [Our Very Best] PILGRIM [Silverplate, 1911] Flat Handle Master Butter Knife
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$9.99
Vtg 1911 Hibbard Spencer Bartlett (OVB) PILGRIM Serving Spoon A1 Silverplate
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$10.00
Vintage pilgrim silver co double plate butter knives 4pcs
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$6.99
2 pilgrim silver co spoons double flatt
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$14.99
Antique Casserole Spoon OVB HIBBARD SPENCER BARTLETT 1911 PILGRIM Silver Plate
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$11.49
OVB [Our Very Best] PILGRIM [Silverplate, 1911] Hollow Handle Fruit Knife
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$12.49
OVB [Our Very Best] PILGRIM [Silverplate, 1911] Flat Handle Butter Spreader
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$49.50
Hibbard Spencer Bartlett Pilgrim 1911 OVB 5 Pie Forks 7 " Silverplate
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$19.99
2 REED & BARTON PICKLE / RELISH / OLIVE FORKS (BENJAMIN'S) PILGRIM 040224a
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$15.00
BEVELED GRAVY LADLE! Vintage PILGRIM silverplate: PIM3 pattern: LOVELY!
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$3.00
Vintage Pilgrim Silver Co. Double Plate PIM3 Pattern Butter Knife
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$50.00
Vintage Pilgrim Silver Co. Double-Plate "Sharon" 6pc Salad Forks Lot Flatware
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$6.00
Pre 60's Pilgrim Silver plated sugar spoon
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$15.00
12 Vintage Hibbard Spencer Bartlet Silver Plate PILGRIM Salad Forks OVB
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$7.99
ANTIQUE COLLECTIBLE SPOON 6" SILVER PLATE - R.W.&S. A1 SECT. - PILGRIM POINT
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$6.99
ANTIQUE COLLECTIBLE SPOON 6" H&T MFG CO. SILVER PLATE - PILGRIM POINT
MORE